CS 59000-HLT: Hands-On Learning Theory

Semester: Fall 2018, also offered on Fall 2021, Fall 2020, Fall 2019, Fall 2017, Fall 2016 and Fall 2015
Time and place: Tuesday and Thursday, 10.30am-11.45am, University Hall 319
Instructor: Jean Honorio
Office hours: Lawson Building 2142-J (Please send an e-mail for appointments)

Imagine you run your favorite machine learning algorithm and obtain impressive results. Some weeks later, you collect more data and your algorithm does not perform very well. What happened? Is your algorithm wrong? Do you need to collect more data for learning? Should you use another algorithm?

In this course, we will analyze when an algorithm works or not, with respect to several aspects, such as how much training data is needed, how much computation, etc. We will learn the main tools for proving theorems and proposing new algorithms, proving their convergence, necessary/sufficient number of samples, etc.

Technically speaking, this course will mainly focus on non-asymptotic analysis of the convergence and statistical efficiency of algorithms. We will introduce several concepts and proof techniques from statistical learning theory, information theory and optimization. The course will include topics such as concentration bounds, empirical risk minimization, PAC-Bayes, Rademacher/Gaussian complexity, Karush-Kuhn-Tucker conditions, primal-dual witness, convergence rates, restricted strong convexity, Fano's inequality, etc.

In a typical course, students work on projects for which the answer is known. Students in Hands-On Learning Theory work in projects for which there is not a known answer. Hands-On Learning Theory requires careful involvement in the project selection, and several meetings (outside the lecture times) in order to bring the projects to a level that is ready for conference submission (with some few extra work after the semester ends).

Learning Objectives

Upon completing the course, students should be able to use different techniques for:


Basic knowledge from calculus and linear algebra is required. Some knowledge or experience with machine learning or data mining is welcome. Necessary concepts from statistics and optimization will be provided during the course.

Registration is by instructor's permission.


There will be four homeworks, one paper review and one project (dates posted on the schedule). All assignments (homeworks, paper review and project) are to be done individually.

The homeworks will be on problems for which the answer is known. The project will be on a problem for which the answer is not known or only partially known.

For the paper review and the project, please pick a relevant topic according to your study goals. I encourage you to pick a paper and project on the same/similar topic. In case you do not have a topic, I can potentially assign you one. I encourage you to pick your topic as soon as possible.

For the paper review, you will write a 2-4 page review of a paper (around 1-2 weeks before the midterms). The goal is to learn to read technically demanding papers critically, and hopefully in the process, generate novel research ideas. Your review should not only summarize the main result of the paper, but critique it, instantiate it on examples, discuss its overall significance, and suggest possible future directions.

For the project, you will write a half-page project plan (in the beginning of the semester), a 2-4 page preliminary results report (around 1-2 weeks after the midterms) and a 4-8 page final results report (around the final exam date). The goal of the project is to apply some of the techniques learnt in class to a particular machine learning problem. Remember, the goal of the course is to learn how to prove theorems regarding sample complexity. Proposing a small modification to a current algorithm that allows proving aspects of the algorithm's behavior is also welcome.


Homeworks: 30%
Paper review: 20%
Preliminary project report: 20%
Final project report: 30%

Late policy

Assignments are to be submitted by the due date listed. Each person will be allowed seven days of extensions which can be applied to any combination of assignments during the semester. Use of a partial day will be counted as a full day. Extensions cannot be used after the final day of classes. Please, use the extension days wisely!

Assignments will NOT BE accepted if they are more than five days late.

Academic Honesty

Please read the departmental academic integrity policy here. This will be followed unless we provide written documentation of exceptions. We encourage you to interact amongst yourselves: you may discuss and obtain help with basic concepts covered in lectures and homework specification (but not solution). However, unless otherwise noted, work turned in should reflect your own efforts and knowledge. Sharing or copying solutions is unacceptable and could result in failure. You are expected to take reasonable precautions to prevent others from using your work.

Additional course policies

Please read the general course policies here.


Date Topic (Tentative) Notes
Tue, Aug 21 Lecture 1: Markov's inequality, Chebyshev's inequality Homework 0: due on Aug 23 at beginning of class - NO EXTENSION DAYS ALLOWED
Thu, Aug 23 Lecture 2: Hoeffding's inequality, empirical risk minimization with a finite hypothesis class Homework 0 due - NO EXTENSION DAYS ALLOWED
Tue, Aug 28 Lecture 3: Fano's inequality, empirical risk minimization with a finite hypothesis class Homework 0 solution
Thu, Aug 30     (lecture continues) Homework 1: due on Sep 4 at beginning of class
Tue, Sep 4 Lecture 4: probably approximately correct (PAC) Bayes, structured prediction Homework 1 due
Thu, Sep 6     (lecture continues)
Tue, Sep 11 Lecture 5: McDiarmid's inequality, sub-Gaussian random variables Homework 1 solution
Thu, Sep 13 Lecture 9: primal-dual witness method, support recovery Homework 2: due on Sep 20 at beginning of class
Tue, Sep 18     (lecture continues)
Thu, Sep 20 Lecture 6: Rademacher complexity, linear prediction Homework 2 due
Tue, Sep 25     (lecture continues) Homework 2 solution
Send me an e-mail with a link to the paper you plan to review
Homework 3: due on Oct 2 at beginning of class
Thu, Sep 27
Tue, Oct 2 Lecture 8: restricted strong convexity, compressed sensing Homework 3 due
Thu, Oct 4 Project plan due (see Assignments for details)
Tue, Oct 9 OCTOBER BREAK Homework 3 solution
Thu, Oct 11     (lecture continues)
Tue, Oct 16 Lecture 7: deterministic and stochastic optimization, convergence rates Paper review due (see Assignments for details)
Thu, Oct 18     (lecture continues)
Tue, Oct 23 Paper presentations and project goals (1 hour per person)
Thu, Oct 25     (presentations continue)
Tue, Oct 30 Lecture 10: growth function, Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension, Sauer-Shelah lemma, Massart lemma
Thu, Nov 1 Preliminary project report due (see Assignments for details)
Tue, Nov 6     (lecture continues)
Thu, Nov 8
Tue, Nov 13 Lecture 11: Le Cam's lemma
Thu, Nov 15     (lecture continues)
Tue, Nov 20
Tue, Nov 27 Project presentations (1 hour per person)
Thu, Nov 29     (presentations continue) Final project report due (see Assignments for details)
Tue, Dec 4
Thu, Dec 6