Review Template

Please use the following template for the paper evaluations. Please make sure it is brief and you submit before 9am on the day of the class.

Paper Title
Reviewer Name

Summarize the main ideas and contributions (each in 1 sentence, max 3.)
Critique the main contribution (e.g., do you think the contribution is a significant one?)
Other comments. For example:
- Are the claims and conclusions follow from the experiments?
- Are the assumptions realistic?
- Are the experiments well designed?
- Are there different experiments that would be more convincing?
- Are there other alternatives the authors should have considered?
- Is the paper free of methodological errors?
List some of the limitations of the work.
What are the specific insights and directions that the work leave open ?

NOTE: The last question iquestion s the most important and is where your opinion is the most valid. Be opinionated. Strong researchers almost always are.