Title:

Reviewer's name:

Practice/App / Research/Tech / Survey/Tutorial:

Very relevant / Relevant / interesting / irrelevant:

How this manuscript advances this field of research and/or contributes
something new to the literature:

Technically Sound?  Yes / Didn't check completely / Partially / No  :

Title/Abstract/Keywords correct:

References sufficient / some missing / excessive:

Introduction state objectives:  Yes / improve / no:

Organization:  Satisfactory / Improve / Poor:

Easy to read / readable with effort / difficult / unreadable:

Overall:  Award / Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor:

Recommendation:  No changes / minor revisions / resubmit / reject:

Comments for author:

Comments not for author: